IP-WARS.NET - a forward command post of the IP Wars
create account| Front Page|Mission|Standard Operating Procedures|Operating Instructions(aka FAQ's)|Privacy Policy|Site Stats/Info|Admin Actions|Search
Sections:General|IP|SCO v World |Microsoft|grok*/OSRM|IPW Site Meta|Logbooks|Diaries|Legal Documents|View All Articles

Condemned to Repeat


By warmcat, Section General Articles
Posted on Fri Nov 5th, 2004 at 11:03:59 EST

Recent events have turned my mind to an arguably historical equivalents to the Free Software movement, the French and Russian revolutions.  (I leave out the American revolution, as being English, it is still just too painful to discuss ;-) )

Like FOSS, these revolutions started out with individuals passionately believing in self-determination, that the citizens should control their own destiny.  Things did not quite turn out like that in either case.  But that is for a future article.  Here is the first part that examines the revolutions' drivers and similarities in the situation today.

First I must say I am not myself Communist nor a historian (I vote Liberal Democrat here in the UK).  I have leant heavily on http://www.historyguide.org/europe/lecture1.html and http://chnm.gmu.edu/revolution/chap1a.html for input.

In the Winter of 1917 Tsar Nicholas III was in power along with his Tsarina of German extraction, in a standard-issue European model monarchy.  Hardship for people outside the inner circle of the elite was real, grinding and constant.  Queues for food waited for hours in icy streets.  Only the relatively well-to-do could afford even wood to heat their houses.  There was no real concern from the monarchy for the state of the life of their subjects, other than to keep the order so they could go on with their luxurious lives without the irritation of difficulties amongst the serfs.  There was a clear and well-defined military and police structure to oppress the citizens.  Over in France in the late 1700's, we see a similar situation.  In a bad year 90% of the peasants are below the starvation level, partly due to an extreme population bulge.  Again at the top of the heap was a Monarchy, King Louis XVI being the unlucky guy without a chair when the music stopped.  There are rigid structures and laws in place to punish anything other than obedience to the will of the regime.

Nowadays we have gone beyond all this nonsense, of course.  Nowadays we have King William Gates III lording it over his transnational subjects (~95% of the computers in the world running his OSes).  We have severe and punitive laws in place to punish anyone who copies content that is the property of the King.  The King also has extraordinary restrictive EULAs and 'activation' software that require you to petition the King, to beg him, before you are allowed to change your hardware.  The king levies his tax for the OSes (regardless if the PC is converted later to another OS) and the Office software, and by being the Lingua Franca that Office software and its fonts are a cost of doing almost any business that exchanges documents.  The King does not care about his citizens suffering from the pestilence of viruses and malware, and enjoys his palaces.

Like in the French revolution, the citizens of Russia were on a slow burn of anger that went on for years before reaching a climax, and in both cases the climax was preceded by intellectual developments, and a fairly lengthy period of digestion and evangalizing of that, which changed the worldview of the people on the lowest rung of the ladder and convinced them they were not going to take any more of this crap.  During the "digestion period", arguably the people holding power were capable to turn the situation around by listening to the complaints and making incremental steps towards what was being demanded, actions that would take the wind from the sails of the revolutionists.  But in both the Russian and French cases, the regime instead tightened its grip on the peasantry, punishing those it saw as working against them harshly and polarizing the situation much worse than it had to be by unfair, capricious and extreme uses of power against the citizens.  By increasing the visibility and manifest unfairness their actions in trying to suppress objections and revolt, they made it much more difficult for support for their position to exist amongst the citizens.  (LESSON: If a bloc forms in opposition to what you are doing, and people are listening to what it has to say, also listen to what they are saying and see if you can deliver it before they deliver it for you.)

Today FOSS is the intellectual special sauce that King William cannot abide.  Very slowly, just like before, the idea that you do not have to pay the tax for software is leaking out into the minds of the citizens.  The idea that viruses and diallers are not normal.  The idea that you can be more than a customer, that you can be included in on defining the way forward to the extent of your capabilities and energies is being preached, but most people are not yet ready for it.  King William's reaction is the BSA, with its shakedowns, audits and settlements according to the laws that King William paid well to have on the books.

In both cases, one one side there are vocal proponents of the status quo and the existing regimes, because they profit from the way things are and sucking up, and attacking the people who want to oust them, makes complete sense.  On the other side are earnest belivers in the new way, pounding their bibles and sermonizing from their pulpits.  Latter-day Trolls, the Agitators / Agents Provocateur, work in whispers in private and in shrieking denunciations to crowds to whip up the passions, for their own exhiliration in the exercise of power over others and to advance their cause if they had one.

Today we have Lyons, Enderle, Didio and the other apologists.  We also have people like RMS with their different intellectual vision firing up the believers.  And of course we have trolls.

For the French, an increase in commercial activity amongst the main citizenry drove an increase in asperations which were doomed to be disappointed by the rigid social hereditary heirarchy.  Even in work various guilds had the force of law to include or exclude practitioners, nothing was a meritocracy.  Playing against this was the intellectual force of the Enlightenment, which promoted the concepts of reason and logic as opposed to Divine right (as of Kings) and mysticism throughout the 1700s.  (This itself was a reaction to the Witch burnings and general religion-driven madness of the previous century).  This gave a worldview which natutally led the oppressed citizens to start to question under what right a certain group of people should lord it over the general citizenry, oppress them, reserve for themselves the status and privileges demanded by the increasingly affluent middle classes, and strictly control their ability to openly discuss matters through censorship.  (LESSON: If pressure is building underneath you, it is time to be more inclusive, not time for a purge.  LESSON: New intellectual concepts can change worldviews, and people with changed worldviews can and will change the world.)

In Russia, the senseless war with the Germans, eating the young of both countries alive, gave an urgency and universal appeal to overthrowing the regime in power.

Today's "war with the germans" is the constant attack by malware because the King does not care, the host of Zombie Windows machines being used to send spam.  The licensing changes to Office that force users to pay the Tax again and again.  The costs of constantly cleaning up after infected machines and trying to delete adware that your browser or email app is happy to install without your consent - every week.

< Darlwinism: How to Destroy a Software Company (10 comments) | Direct TV loses a Summary Judgement (16 comments) >
Display: Sort:
Condemned to Repeat | 21 comments (21 topical, 0 editorial, 8 hidden)
Re: Condemned to Repeat (3.83 / 6) (#3)
by pgk (PG_King zzzzzzz (yahoo.com)) on Fri Nov 5th, 2004 at 14:05:30 EST
(User Info)
> Linux is not their reason for existing, profit is.

Same as every commercial entity, good of the shareholders.

It's actually quite interesting in general, who are "our" allies. As both we and they change.

Consider Libiya, a rogue terrorist state for as long as I can remember now being accepted back into the fold. 20 years from now I guess the terrorist state bit will by many be long forgotten 50 years certainly.
Afghanistan who we supplied arms and training to in the not too distant past, but then with Bin Laden etc....

IBM as you say will move where the profit is, and I guess so will RedHat as RedHat expands and grows and finds maybe a market for non-linux wares will it in time drop linux? 20 years from now? 50 years from now?

I guess we just have to look at the now and where their current future plans are leading.

Re: Condemned to Repeat (3.77 / 9) (#6)
by Potential Recruit on Sat Nov 6th, 2004 at 20:17:32 EST
There are a couple of important points about the French revolution, that didn't make it into the article. First, the revolution actually came from an attempt at liberalization. A meeting of the Estates General was called (a weird sort of parliament). The king and his advisors thought they could control the situation. They were sabotaged by a group of liberal nobles who thought they could control the situation. Neither could, and step by step it went out of control.

The result was a revolutionary government - the convention. There was horrible bloodletting in the provinces as the convention fought for control, including mass drownings (noyages) and the like.

Once in control, the factions began to be purged, one at a time. The remaining factions cooperated with the purges, either out of fear or for political gain, and then they were purged in turn. Finally, the convention united out of fear that they might be next and had Robespierre, the architect of the later purges, executed with his henchman Saint Just.

There followed a period of reaction ending in the Napoleanic Empire. Many of the social and economic reforms of the revolution remained and were even added to, but political power was held by one man.

Let's hope our revolution doesn't follow this model too closely. A kinder gentler Microsoft could be the first step. It may encorage opposition rather than quiet it, not that they have much choice.

Re: Condemned to Repeat (3.40 / 5) (#1)
by ColonelZen (tzellers lieth within pobox of thy kingdom com) on Fri Nov 5th, 2004 at 12:59:33 EST
(User Info)
Interesting anlogy.  I personally regard historical research as tedious though important ala Santayana.  What I would like to see sometime, somewhere is how "corporatism" is devolving into something like fuedal states.  Niven and Pournelle did it fictionally - with a positive outlook, yet - in "Oath of Fealty", but If someone has pointers to articles where it is limned from the real world I would be grateful.  

MS seems to be sort of the tip of the iceberg.  IBM is a better example as I, personally, have greater loyalty to IBM (from outside, yet, though respect is an arguably better word, but where does one end and the other begin?) than to many of my titular political affiliations.

-- TWZ

  • Re: Condemned to Repeat by Potential Recruit, 11/05/2004 13:54:31 EST (4.00 / 5)
    • Re: Condemned to Repeat by ColonelZen, 11/05/2004 14:10:07 EST (3.80 / 5)
      • Re: Condemned to Repeat by edlin user, 11/06/2004 19:29:30 EST (3.71 / 7)
        • Re: Condemned to Repeat by ColonelZen, 11/07/2004 14:07:58 EST (3.88 / 9)
Bye bye spambot (none / 1) (#14)
by Potential Recruit on Mon Nov 27th, 2006 at 12:13:07 EST
This used to be a spambot post that is flooding the site. Due to volume, I had to resort to this while I work to block access by these bots. My apologies - thanks for your patience.

Jeff

Bye bye spambot (none / 1) (#15)
by Potential Recruit on Mon Nov 27th, 2006 at 12:14:10 EST
This used to be a spambot post that is flooding the site. Due to volume, I had to resort to this while I work to block access by these bots. My apologies - thanks for your patience.

Jeff

Bye bye spambot (none / 1) (#16)
by Potential Recruit on Mon Nov 27th, 2006 at 13:45:28 EST
This used to be a spambot post that is flooding the site. Due to volume, I had to resort to this while I work to block access by these bots. My apologies - thanks for your patience.

Jeff

Bye bye spambot (none / 1) (#17)
by Potential Recruit on Mon Nov 27th, 2006 at 13:46:27 EST
This used to be a spambot post that is flooding the site. Due to volume, I had to resort to this while I work to block access by these bots. My apologies - thanks for your patience.

Jeff

Bye bye spambot (none / 0) (#20)
by Potential Recruit on Tue Nov 28th, 2006 at 13:15:47 EST
This used to be a spambot post that is flooding the site. Due to volume, I had to resort to this while I work to block access by these bots. My apologies - thanks for your patience.

Jeff

Bye bye spambot (none / 0) (#21)
by Potential Recruit on Tue Nov 28th, 2006 at 13:33:58 EST
This used to be a spambot post that is flooding the site. Due to volume, I had to resort to this while I work to block access by these bots. My apologies - thanks for your patience.

Jeff

Condemned to Repeat | 21 comments (21 topical, 0 editorial, 8 hidden)
Display: Sort:

Links

Firefox 2

Use OpenOffice.org

Add to Technorati Favorites

Join EFF Today

ToTehMoon web site button

~ Merkey v The Internet et al Docs
~ Yahoeuvre
~ tuxrocks.com (SCO cases legal docs)
~ scofacts.org
~ eagle.petrofsky.org
~ Zen's Den
~ Yahoo SCOX Message Board
~ Lamlaw
~ Microsoft Watch
~ Groklaw
~ Korgwal - a Groklaw mirror
~ nosoftwarepatents.com
~ Flame Warriors
~ SCOXE Wars
~ Get your Merkey Number here!
~ Digital Law Online

Recent Comments

Breaking News and External Article Comments
General News – General Articles
by ColonelZen, January 5
60 comments
» SCO Lifeboat List from Stats_for_all – AncientBrit, May 6
» Not a single comment on the Novell... – sphealey, Jul 22
» Re: Not a single comment on the Novell... – AncientBrit, Aug 8

Eagle Loses Appeals
General News – General Articles
by JCausey, December 15
1 comment
» Re: Eagle Loses Appeals – br3n, Jan 7

The Chinese Room Revisited, Thoughts on...
General News – Diary
by ColonelZen, November 24
1 comment
» Re: The Chinese Room Revisited,... – ColonelZen, Nov 24

How to Transition a Windows Shop to Linux
General News – General Articles
by JCausey, November 21
3 comments
» Re: How to Transition a Windows Shop to... – ColonelZen, Nov 22
» Re: How to Transition a Windows Shop to... – JCausey, Nov 23
» Re: How to Transition a Windows Shop to... – ColonelZen, Nov 23

Advocacy
General News – Diary
by br3n, October 29
3 comments
» Re: Advocacy – br3n, Nov 2
» Re: Advocacy – ColonelZen, Nov 2
» Re: Advocacy – br3n, Nov 4

Very Bad News for Darl and Ralph
SCO v The World – Diary
by ColonelZen, October 13
7 comments
» Re: OT advocacy – br3n, Oct 26
» Re: OT advocacy – JCausey, Oct 28
» Re: OT advocacy – br3n, Oct 29

Some SCOX Financial Analysis
SCO v The World – SCO Related Articles
by JCausey, September 21
13 comments
» Re: Some SCOX Financial Analysis – br3n, Oct 3
» Re: Some SCOX Financial Analysis – ColonelZen, Oct 3
» Re: Some SCOX Financial Analysis – br3n, Oct 6

Open Source in Education - Opening Doors
General News – General Articles
by JCausey, September 28
1 comment
» Re: Open Source in Education - Opening... – br3n, Sep 29

An IPOWER ful experience
General News – Diary
by ColonelZen, September 25
6 comments
» IPOWER SysAdmin Doesn't Do Weekends!! – ColonelZen, Sep 29
» Re: An IPOWER ful experience – ColonelZen, Sep 29
» Re: An IPOWER ful experience – ColonelZen, Sep 29

Learning C#
Microsoft – Diary
by ColonelZen, September 23
1 comment
» Re: Learning C# – ColonelZen, Sep 23

Comment search...

Recent Diaries

SCO has a Potential and Credible BILLION Dollar Liability
by ColonelZen - March 15

The Chinese Room Revisited, Thoughts on Consciousness
by ColonelZen - November 24
1 comment


Advocacy
by br3n - October 29
3 comments


An IPOWER ful experience
by ColonelZen - September 25
6 comments


Learning C#
by ColonelZen - September 23
1 comment


Getting ruby DBI for Mysql and Postgresql working on FC 6
by ColonelZen - March 7

Declaration of Linus Torvalds
by nedu - February 13
1 comment


Declaration of M. Douglas McIlroy
by nedu - February 12
6 comments


Declaration of Ulrich Drepper
by nedu - February 11
1 comment


Declaration of K. Y. Srinivasan
by nedu - February 11


More Diaries...

Login

Make a new account

Username:
Password:

Older Stories

Monday May 28th
Why SCO Does Not Own the Unix Copyrights
   (0 comments)

Thursday April 5th
It Can Really Happen - Eagle Broadband Delisting from AMEX
   (5 comments)

Monday March 12th
OpenOffice.org Sends Open Letter to Dell
   (0 comments)

Tuesday March 6th
Preliminary Order in Prohibition
   (2 comments)

Monday January 15th
[Linux-ia64] optimizing __copy_user
   (12 comments)

Older Stories...

Related Links

~ http://www .historyguide.org/europe/lecture1.html
~ http://chn m.gmu.edu/revolution/chap1a.html
~ More on
~ Also by warmcat

SourceForge Logo Powered by Scoop

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies or owners.
Comments, articles and logbooks are owned by the Poster. By posting on the ip-wars.net web site, all posters grant a license to ip-wars.net to publish the content and release it pursuant to the Creative Commons License that covers the rest of the site. For more details, please check out the Standard Operating Procedures. Also, please read the Privacy Policy for the site. Finally, DO NOT send e-mail to the site owner (Jeff Causey) unless you have read and agree to the terms regarding e-mail included in the Standard Operating Procedures.
Everything else © 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 ip-wars.net and Jeffrey G. Causey and is licensed under a
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.